I had such high hopes for this place when we found out its history. At first, the local Mormons were wary of these outsiders, and it took the Hell's Backbone Grill several years to get its liquor license from the county. You can read more about the story on their website, but it's pretty interesting and inspiring, for the dining community at least.
One look at the menu, though, and I was already confused. Several of the dishes looked like something from an Applebee's menu. The specials (a stuffed zucchini and an enchilada) sounded like home cooking. Still, we wanted to give it a fair shot, and so ordered a wide variety of appetizers.
The first few appetizers were fine, but completely uninteresting. The best thing was a fennel salad with lemon-tarragon vinaigrette. The "minted peas" were just snow peas with a trace of mint. Everything was very fresh, but the preparation wasn't anything I'd have been proud of if I had it made for myself. And, as you can tell from the pictures, the chefs were obsessed with garnishing everything, and I mean EVERYTHING, with edible flowers from their garden. They were too big, and while they may have been edible, they certainly didn't taste good. A lot of insects are edible too, you know?
The fennel saladHowever, the atrocities came in the form of entrees. My pork chop was rare in the middle. Only red meat should be served rare. The peach barbecue sauce it came with was decent, I guess, but I couldn't get over the fact that they had served me uncooked white meat. Lauren's trout was sickly sweet, glazed with way too much molasses. All the garnishes were steamed or grilled vegetables, which again made me feel like I was eating mediocre home cooking. With most of the entrees priced over $30, this was mind-blowing. How the people at Zagat gave it such a high rating is beyond me.
Pork chop, raw
TroutWe finished with uninteresting desserts like an apricot fool and some apple pie. I couldn't help but feel let down by the place. In Europe, these types of restaurants exist everywhere, but the quality is on par with, if not better than big city restaurants. In Boulder, UT, all it takes to gain a little fame is a poisonous pork chop and a vegetable garden. It just shows how far we have to go. New York, Chicago, DC, San Francisco, etc. may have great food, but it's in the heartland that you can truly define a culinary culture. And judging by this place, the heartland kinda sucks right now.


